What could “sin” mean from a queer perspective?

“Sin” isn’t sexy. Of all concepts from religion that are well-known nowadays, “sin” has perhaps the least caché. Other religious concepts enjoy a more benign reputation (saint? charity? visit the sick? mercy? forgiveness?) and quite a number of other religious concepts actually do enjoy a certain caché in contemporary popular culture (the Divine? ritual? meditation? grace?).

“Sin,” however, evokes finger-wagging or, worse, the moral condemnation that prim, patriarchal, and almost always hypocritical self-important and self-righteous religious folks use to prop themselves up and put others down. “Sin” in this register is really not at all sexy. 

So what possible relevance could this religious term bear for regular people today? What does “sin” look like from a contemporary queer perspective?  

Today is Ash Wednesday. Today Christians in the West mark themselves with ashes to signal the start of a season of contrition, penance, and repentance from, you guessed it, sin. 

I am not closeted about being Catholic. Indeed, as much as I jokingly refer to myself sometimes as a “professional homosexual,” I equally qualify as a “professional Catholic.” I don’t make this claim because I go to Mass most Sundays or even because last year I taught catechism to fifth graders in my parish, but because I am a trained Catholic theologian, in fact, a card-carrying member of the Catholic Theological Society of America. 

Yet, at Flourishing Gays, I don’t exactly lead with this part of myself. So many LGBTQ+ people have left religion entirely—whether because of problematic and damaging personal experiences they’ve had with religious figures or religious discourse, or because of the systemic collusion of religious institution with malign forces of patriarchy, racism, colonialism or other oppressions—that strident religious signals can put LGBTQ+ folks on alert. 

Queer people commonly experience religious trauma, and so they justifiably keep their distance from so-called “organized religion.” 

As founder of Flourishing Gays, I generally therefore translate my own religious knowledge and beliefs into a secular idiom. I’m open about my religious orientation, and indeed my expertise as a scholar of my own Christian tradition as well as the Islamic tradition. These are important parts of who I am and the life I have led. But I hold these facets of myself carefully when meeting folks in a Flourishing Gays context or in my client work.

But today, Ash Wednesday, with an ashen cross marked on my forehead, I’m bringing this Catholic part of me forward more directly, and I’m venturing some queer theological reflection in this Flourishing Gays space, while assuming that the vast majority of readers regard religion with some caution, or even disdain.

This morning I got to thinking about “sin,” and what possible value this idea could have for LGBTQ+ folks who are not particularly religious or even anti-religious. So, whatever your attitude towards or relationship with religion, I invite you to try on this take on “sin” that I offer this Ash Wednesday: 

From a queer perspective, I regard sin as a betrayal of love. To put it more directly, we sin when we betray love. 

When I say betraying love, I don’t mean merely passing over opportunities to love or to practice compassion — These opportunities are innumerable. Indeed, these countless opportunities to love or exercise compassion in the world may all be portals into life-giving virtue and (re-)connection with what most matters. But not seizing such an opportunity, not entering into such a portal — and again they are innumerable — this is no betrayal. It might be imperfection not to love at every opportunity, and it is certainly a results of our limitations, but imperfection is our nature. It is no betrayal to be what we are, that is, finite, limited creatures.

What I am reflecting on today is not imperfection, but rather transgressions that damage, that do evil, that are evil. Indeed, at the heart of this reflection on “sin” is the question, from a queer perspective today, what is evil?

Here’s my hot take from a queer perspective that I believe can spaciously encompass secular, non-religious, and antireligious folks as well as the most fervently religious queer people:

Evil means to take to heart the beliefs that homophobia systemically tries to impose on us. 

What are some of these beliefs that systemic homophobia tries to impose us?

  1. You have no power.
  2. Hope is ridiculous.
  3. None of us matters.
  4. The essence of queer relationship is stepping on people like ladder rungs. 
  5. It would be better if I were not alive. 

1. Homophobia strives to make LGBTQ+ people believe that we have no power, no agency, no potential to change society or its norms to make room for us, our queer families, or our ways of living. 

The queer sin that derives from believing this precept is complacency.

2. Homophobia strives to make LGBTQ+ people believe that hope is ridiculous. In 1978, at the behest of queer martyr Harvey Milk, artist Gilbert Baker designed the rainbow flag as a symbol of pride for the gay community. Today, the rainbow ranks as most prominent symbol for our community. Baker took this natural celestial phenomenon of ephemeral beauty and imbued it with new meaning. The authors of the book of Genesis had done the same some around 2500 years before, making the rainbow a symbol of hope following the floods that spared Noah and his ark full of diverse creatures.

Since the rainbow flag was first flown on June 25, 1978, for the San Francisco Gay Freedom Day, it has held for LGBTQ+ people a meaning of hope for liberation for the beautiful array of weird and wonderful bodies, pleasures, genders, and sexual expressions in our community. Yet, homophobia ridicules us and our hope for queer liberation.

The queer sin that derives from believing this precept is cynicism.

3. Homophobia strives to make LGBTQ+ people believe that none of us matters. So many of the struggles of queer people center on reclaiming our self-worth. After so many voices and so many forces pushing a message of despicable worthlessness on us as sick, demented, perverted, laughable, disgraceful, shameful, we struggle to remember our dignity. LGBTQ+ people must do extraordinary work to remember their intrinsic and inalienable and inestimable value and worth as human beings. Yet, the forces of homophobia pressure us to disown our dignity. As we betray ourselves, we betray the inestimable value of each other as well. We act trashy. We put each other down. We let ourselves be used and abused.

The queer sin that derives from believing this precept is debasing.

4. Homophobia strives to make LGBTQ+ people believe that the essence of queer relationship is stepping on people as if they were ladder rungs. Homophobia projects the precept that gay sex is animalistic, bestial, base lust, and nothing more. Queer love is an oxymoron, says the voice homophobic respectability and conventional morality. Focusing especially on gay male sex, the forces of homophobia demean gay relationships as fundamentally and intrinsically exploitative. While good (straight) sex expresses love and creates new life, gay men fucking are just using each other for cheap thrills. When LGBTQ+ folks take such messages to heart, they make others their sexual exploits, and/ or they become exploits—the (straight) proverbial “notch in the bedpost.”

The queer sin that derives from believing this precept is exploiting.

5. Homophobia strives to make LGBTQ+ people believe that it would be better if we were not alive. LGBTQ+ people should disappear off the face of the earth. Trans people don’t exist. They’re deluded in claiming their identity as such. Their passports must recognize their chromomal sex. Gay and lesbian and trans and queer people bring shame unto their families and their communities. They are a disgrace. They deserve to die.

When LGBTQ+ folks take such existentially destructive messages to heart, they give into the temptation to fade into non-existence.

The queer sin that derives from believing this precept is absence.

Thanks for your consideration of these reflections on “sin” from the queer perspective I am bringing this Ash Wednesday. I would be very grateful to hear from you about this. How are these ponderings landing with you? Whether you’re gay or straight, or anywhere in between (!), I would love to hear what these reflections bring up for you.

As always, my hope in writing is to evoke and foster greater flourishing in you and in all. Have these reflections on this very unsexy topic of sin brought up any fresh perspectives for you of how and where you might find your way to greater flourishing? Or how you might foster greater flourishing for others?

I genuinely look forward to hearing from you.

About the Author

Share:

More Posts

What’s your avocado toast?

Waking up, slowly, groggily. White hazy skies, plush cotton with jagged, industrial parts cutting off the space and marking the incursion of cityscape. Roofs, windows, edges, guardrails. Blue colors the billowing brightness. Fire escape stairs sleek and angled.

Tend the World, Within

Tend the World, Within TL;DR  Amidst the world’s havoc, tend your yearnings to find your flourishing and heal the world. Disorder and injustice are increasing these days so