We are Them
ORDER! Order in the court! Order in the public square!
We demand law and order!
For some Americans this demand for “order” might mean an end to rowdiness by the kids and Black folk and their starry-eyed friends out in the streets.
For protesters and people of color, this demand might be for a new order, one with truly equal protection under the law, the presumption of innocence, and trustworthy police who safeguard everyone’s human and civil rights.
Polarization, division, and demonization corrode commitments to the common good. Forces seemingly larger than any of us pit us against one another.
Police versus Black men
People of Color versus White people
Straights versus Gays
Queer people of color versus white gay men
Our social fabric stretches, strains, tears under the stress of heavy knees on vulnerable necks. Protesters march and shout and cry out for justice against militarized muscle and faux religious bravado. Teenagers act up and act out breaking windows on Fifth Avenue and in SoHo, taking Nike shoes and spray painting “Fuck 12” on boarded up stores. “Anti-fa(scism)” becomes a bad word among some Americans.
Yet, we are them. They are us. We are one.
We all have work to do to find and see within ourselves that Other who seems so wrong, so stupid, so bad, so immature. (Hint: This is not an intellectual exercise.)
Now is a time to soften the sharp edges within our self-definition that delimits our range of possibility. That is the work of personal growth and leadership development. “Expansion” is a word used to talk about growing and learning of a kind that is not about skills and knowledge, but rather about the capacity of our mindset to hold alternative perspectives, even paradoxes.
Do you aspire to “Be the change that you want to see in the world”?
Expand yourself to find and love those parts of yourself that are the rowdy looter, that are the white nationalist, that are the macho billy club and even the suffocating knee of aggressive police. (Hint: This work happens below the neck, in our tender parts and nether-regions.)
In my conversation (recorded before George Floyd’s death) with Jan Rybeck, an expert in adult human development, we discuss this kind of personal change and expansion, which is known by specialists as “vertical development.”
Open yourself to hold and embrace more than you currently can. Your opening and holding more changes your world and it changes the world.
In early June 2020, I tuned into the seething of New York City and the strife and confusion in Minneapolis, and throughout the USA. While feeling fear at police brutality and righteous rage at the legacy of slavery that still powers and electrifies America, I also found in myself the desire for business as usual, for comfort and ease, for calm, and–yes–for privilege. (Hint: This is spiritual work, emotional work.)
This was my inner work at the height of the Black Lives Matter movement, expanding myself to hold with compassion all the sides of the national crisis that convulsed America. This work does not mean holding all sides as just and good and right. I did not then and do not now. In fact, I can’t even get my head around all positions.
Honestly, it was far beyond my intellectual ability during the time of George Floyd’s murder and the upsurge of outrage in American society that followed even to formulate a cogent or reasonable argument for supporting the Trump administration (regime?) or the Members of Congress who colluded with Trump and gave his administration cover.
But I can (at times) imaginatively and affectively put myself in the place of those that vote for them and support them. I can (at times) imagine what it might be like to be an aggressive even murderous policeman. I can (at times) feel into what it might be like to disdain protesters and looters, flex my muscles, summon the troops, and self-righteously call for “law and order” in the land.
This is not an intellectual exercise. This is an affair of the heart. This takes guts. Expanding ourselves in this journey of vertical development increases our capacity to navigate complexity, to embody justice, and to love powerfully.
This work of increasingly embracing the whole may be your own healing work these days.
Rather than stepping with compassion into someone else’s place, you may instead need simply to tend to your own re-activated trauma right now.
The traumas of my life have not been racial. In fact, I benefit from white privilege. Anti-Black racism interweaves with the fabric of American society, in which my Irish and Italian immigrant forefathers and foremothers became White and stepped into the (white?) American dream.
For folks bearing the wounds of racial trauma, the inner work that may have been prompted by George Floyd’s murder is first of all about healing, which is a painstaking and recursive process. That healing includes releasing defensive and protective measures so that waves of anger, sadness, fear, and grief can arise and course through the body. That healing also requires telling the stories of your trauma. Putting words to unspeakable terror, torment, abuse, and anguish, we make sense of trauma so as to weave back together the pieces of ourselves. Healing from trauma also requires calm rest and recovery in safety.
Protests and the pauses after them are places where this healing work can happen communally.
This difference between White people’s experience of the national crisis prompted by George Floyd’s murder and Black people’s is part of why dismantling systemic racism is White people’s responsibility and problem to solve. Homophobia is straight people’s responsibility and problem to solve. Sexism is men’s responsibility and problem to solve.



